92/94

The 2023 Musigny Grand Cru is 100% whole bunch as usual. Following the Bonnes-Mares and Charmes-Chambertin, I must admit that it is not my favorite on the nose, the stems too prominent and occluding the fruit profile/terroir. The palate is medium-bodied with a fresh opening, well balanced with fine tannins, although again, the stems seem to do all the talking at the moment. Is there the fruit concentration/density to fully subsume the stalks with bottle age?

93/96

(from two parcels totaling .21 ha). Restrained, elegant and ultra-pure aromas are equally floral-infused but even spicier with a blend of black cherry, jasmine tea, cinnamon and orange peel scents. The mouthfeel of the intense and solidly concentrated flavors matches the nose for refinement while exuding evident minerality on the stunningly long, balanced and very classy finale. This is superb and one to look for.

100 point

The nose shows minerals, earth, dark red and black fruit, forest floor, truffles, crushed stones, oyster shells, red mahogany, spices and dried rose petals. The palate is taut and energetic, with firmly framed tannins and bright acidity that bring tension and persistence. It has a luscious, silken mouthfeel and an endless, luxurious finish. Made from vines planted in 1970 and 1989. Drink or hold. Only 900 bottles made.